Skip to content

Can The Lost Apothecary’s Potions Truly Captivate You?

The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner

Welcome to the intriguing world of 'The Lost Apothecary,' a debut novel by Sarah Penner that promises a compelling blend of historical fiction and mystery. Set against the backdrop of 18th century London and present-day, the story follows the lives of three women—Nella, Eliza, and Caroline—whose lives intertwine through a series of dark and fascinating events. Nella, an apothecary, crafts secret potions for women seeking revenge, while young Eliza becomes an unexpected accomplice. Fast forward to present-day London, where Caroline stumbles upon an old vial by the Thames, sparking her quest to uncover the mysteries of the past.

But does this novel truly deliver on its promise of captivating historical intrigue and strong female protagonists? Can Penner's storytelling transport us seamlessly between centuries, and do her characters leave a lasting impression? As we delve into this review, we'll uncover whether 'The Lost Apothecary' casts a spell on its readers or if it simply leaves us yearning for more. Let's embark on this literary journey and see what secrets lie within.


    A Peek into The Lost Apothecary

    From the moment you lay eyes on 'The Lost Apothecary,' its captivating cover art and intriguing title draw you in. The initial impression is one of mystery and allure, promising an escape into a bygone era filled with secrets and suspense. The book's physical dimensions make it a comfortable read, and its 352 pages are a manageable length for a weekend indulgence. Opening the book, the narrative style quickly grabs your attention. Penner's descriptive language paints vivid pictures of 1791 London, with its dark alleys and hidden corners where Nella's apothecary operates. The transition to present-day London is seamless, with Caroline's storyline providing a modern contrast to the historical narrative. The initial chapters are engaging, introducing us to well-crafted characters whose stories promise to intertwine in unexpected ways. However, some early skepticism arises regarding the plausibility of Nella's secretive operations and the ease with which Caroline stumbles upon the vial. These elements set the stage for a gripping tale, but also leave room for doubt about the story's believability.

    Nella's Apothecary: A World of Secrets

    One of the most intriguing aspects of 'The Lost Apothecary' is the world of Nella, the apothecary. Set in the dark and mysterious alleys of 18th century London, Nella's shop is a sanctuary for women seeking solutions to their troubles—often of a sinister nature. Penner excels in describing the apothecary's shelves lined with jars of exotic ingredients and the meticulous process Nella follows to create her potions. This feature not only adds depth to the historical setting but also highlights the limited options available to women during that era. Nella's character, with her blend of knowledge and secrecy, becomes a symbol of female resilience and ingenuity.

    Eliza's Innocence and Curiosity

    Eliza, a twelve-year-old girl, brings a unique perspective to the story. Her innocence and curiosity drive much of the plot's early development. Despite her young age, Eliza's interactions with Nella reveal a maturity beyond her years, shaped by the harsh realities of her life as a servant. Her unexpected bond with Nella provides a touching contrast to the darker themes of the novel. However, her naiveté and the reliance on magic towards the end of the story may challenge the reader's suspension of disbelief. Eliza's character serves as a bridge between the past and the present, with her story echoing through the centuries to Caroline's discoveries.

    Caroline's Journey of Self-Discovery

    In the present day, Caroline's storyline adds a modern twist to the narrative. Her journey begins with a solo trip to London, a decision spurred by her husband's infidelity. This personal crisis propels Caroline into a quest for identity and purpose, far removed from her planned anniversary celebration. As she delves into the history of the vial she finds, Caroline's passion for British history and her rediscovery of herself unfold in a relatable and inspiring manner. Her character's evolution from a heartbroken wife to a determined historian forms a significant part of the novel's appeal.

    Historical Intrigue: The Apothecary Murders

    The mystery of the 'Apothecary murders' serves as a central plot element, weaving together the lives of Nella, Eliza, and Caroline. This feature keeps the reader engaged as they piece together the clues from the past and present. The historical intrigue is enhanced by Penner's attention to detail, from the descriptions of 18th century London to the meticulous research Caroline undertakes. The unfolding mystery not only drives the narrative but also highlights themes of justice and retribution, especially in a society that often left women with few options.

    The Power of Female Friendship

    At its core, 'The Lost Apothecary' is a story about the strength of female friendships. Nella and Eliza's bond in the past, and Caroline's connections in the present, emphasize the importance of solidarity among women. These relationships provide emotional depth and highlight the resilience required to navigate a world often dominated by unsympathetic male characters. The novel celebrates the power of friendship to overcome adversity, a theme that resonates across both timelines and adds a heartwarming element to the story.

    Who Will Love The Lost Apothecary?

    'The Lost Apothecary' is ideal for readers who enjoy historical fiction with strong female protagonists. Fans of dual timeline narratives will appreciate how Penner seamlessly weaves together the past and present. Those with an interest in herbal lore and the historical roles of women will find the apothecary's world particularly fascinating. The novel's exploration of friendship and resilience will resonate with readers who value emotional depth in their stories.

    However, it may not appeal to those who prefer straightforward narratives without magical elements or those who might find the plot's plausibility stretched in places. If you're intrigued by the idea of uncovering hidden histories and enjoy a good mystery with richly developed characters, 'The Lost Apothecary' is a book you'll want to add to your reading list.

    What Readers Are Saying

    The reception of 'The Lost Apothecary' has been largely positive, with readers praising its compelling narrative and strong character development. Many have found the dual timelines engaging, appreciating the seamless transition between 1791 London and the present day. The intricate details of Nella's apothecary and Caroline's modern-day discoveries have captivated readers, making the book hard to put down.

    Common praises highlight the novel's focus on the untold stories of women and the strength of female friendships. Readers have also commended Penner's descriptive writing, which brings the historical setting to life and adds depth to the characters' experiences. However, some have noted that certain plot points, such as Nella's lack of protective measures for her identity and Eliza's magical resolution, can strain believability. Despite these criticisms, the overall consensus is that 'The Lost Apothecary' offers an enjoyable and thought-provoking read.

    Testimonials from readers often emphasize how the book's unique premise and engaging storytelling kept them hooked from start to finish. Notable mentions include the emotional depth of the characters and the novel's ability to shed light on historical injustices faced by women. While there are minor criticisms, the book's ability to weave a captivating tale of mystery and resilience has left a lasting impression on many.


    • Engaging dual timelines
    • Strong, well-developed female characters
    • Compelling historical details
    • Fast-paced, engrossing plot
    • Richly atmospheric settings

    Possible Downsides:

    • Some plot points are hard to believe
    • Certain characters lack depth
    • Abrupt reliance on magic for resolution
    • Minor characters not fully fleshed out
    • Unsympathetic male characters

    Our Verdict

    The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner gets a rating of 4.3 out of 5.

    If you're a fan of historical fiction, strong female characters, and mysteries that span centuries, 'The Lost Apothecary' is a must-read. Its engaging plot and richly developed characters make it a standout debut novel worth adding to your collection.

    For more information and the latest prices, go to: – Free and quick delivery on most items
    • Sarah is our dedicated in-house product researcher. Based in the bustling city of Chicago, she works from the comfort of her home, where she skillfully balances her professional responsibilities with her role as a wife, mother of two energetic kids and a loving dog owner.